Skip To Main Content

# Minn.-Crookston (6-19,0-17 NSIC) -VS- # Concordia-St. Paul (21-4,16-1 NSIC)

Box Score

Minn.-Crookston logo
0
vs
Concordia-St. Paul logo
3

# Minn.-Crookston (6-19,0-17 NSIC)
-VS-
# Concordia-St. Paul (21-4,16-1 NSIC)

Team Score By Period
Team 1 2 3
Minn.-Crookston UMC 14 20 14
Winner Concordia-St. Paul CSP 25 25 25
Date:
11/7/2025
Time:
6:00 pm
Site:
Saint Paul, MN (Gangelhoff Center)
Attendance:
365
VIEW
Match History vs Minn.-Crookston

Match Details

Game Statistics By Set
Set Minn.-Crookston Concordia-St. Paul
K E TA % K E TA %
Set #1 9 2 36 0.194 18 1 41 0.415
Set #2 9 3 41 0.146 18 10 52 0.154
Set #3 6 3 31 0.097 20 4 33 0.485
Total 24 8 108 .148 56 15 126 .325
Team Statistical Comparison
Statistic Team Comparison
UMC - CSP
Points
28.0
66.0
Kills
24
56
Aces
2
7
Blocks
2
3
Assists
24
52
Digs
48
69

Game Leaders

UMC - Leaders
Statistic Leaders
Kills Carsten, Madison (6), Scharold, Lexi (6), Muth, Carizma (4)
Aces Melby, Dana (1), Muth, Carizma (1)
Blocks Malek, Emma (2), Haag, Sophia (1)
Assists Melby, Dana (12), Ehresmann, Ellery (8), Muth, Carizma (2)
Digs Muth, Carizma (15), Schnettler, Lauren (12), Melby, Dana (6)
CSP - Leaders
Statistic Leaders
Kills Sieling, Ellie (16), Nold, Makenna (13), Straub, Mehlayna (12)
Aces Rolbiecki, Natalee (3), Sieling, Ellie (2), Sieling, Cassie (1)
Blocks Straub, Mehlayna (3), Waterman, Audrey (2)
Assists Hickey, Reagan (24), Waterman, Audrey (22), Sieling, Cassie (5)
Digs Sieling, Cassie (26), Sieling, Ellie (13), Rolbiecki, Natalee (10)

Individual Statistics

Minn.-Crookston (6-19,0-17 NSIC)

UMC - Individual
# Player SP Attack Set Serve Block Def Rec
K E TA Pct A E SA SE SA-SE BS BA BE DIG BHE RE Pts
2 2 Carsten, Madison 3 6 3 45 .067 1 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 1 5 0 1 6.0
19 19 Malek, Emma 3 2 1 10 .100 0 0 0 1 0-1 1 1 0 2 0 0 3.5
15 15 Melby, Dana 3 0 0 1 .000 12 0 1 0 1-0 0 0 0 6 0 0 1.0
20 20 Muth, Carizma 3 4 4 20 .000 2 1 1 0 1-0 0 0 0 15 0 0 5.0
10 10 Schoenfelder, Megan 3 4 0 8 .500 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 1 0 0 4.0
5 5 Scharold, Lexi 3 6 0 14 .429 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 6.0
3 3 Schnettler, Lauren 3 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 2 0-2 0 0 0 12 0 4 0.0
1 1 Ehresmann, Ellery 3 0 0 3 .000 8 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 6 0 0 0.0
14 14 Haag, Sophia 3 2 0 7 .286 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 1 0 1 0 0 2.5
18 18 Venditto, Adrienne 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0
Totals 24 8 108 .148 24 1 2 3 2-3 1 2 1 48 0 7 28
UMC - Individual
# Player SP Block Def Rec Pts
BS BA BE DIG BHE RE
2 2 Carsten, Madison 3 0 0 1 5 0 1 6.0
19 19 Malek, Emma 3 1 1 0 2 0 0 3.5
15 15 Melby, Dana 3 0 0 0 6 0 0 1.0
20 20 Muth, Carizma 3 0 0 0 15 0 0 5.0
10 10 Schoenfelder, Megan 3 0 0 0 1 0 0 4.0
5 5 Scharold, Lexi 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 6.0
3 3 Schnettler, Lauren 3 0 0 0 12 0 4 0.0
1 1 Ehresmann, Ellery 3 0 0 0 6 0 0 0.0
14 14 Haag, Sophia 3 0 1 0 1 0 0 2.5
18 18 Venditto, Adrienne 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0
Totals 1 2 1 48 0 7 28

Concordia-St. Paul (21-4,16-1 NSIC)

CSP - Individual
# Player SP Attack Set Serve Block Def Rec
K E TA Pct A E SA SE SA-SE BS BA BE DIG BHE RE Pts
12 12 Rolbiecki, Natalee 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 1 3-1 0 0 0 10 0 0 3.0
6 6 Sieling, Ellie 3 16 3 37 .351 1 0 2 1 2-1 0 0 0 13 0 1 18.0
7 7 Sieling, Cassie 3 0 0 0 0 5 0 1 1 1-1 0 0 0 26 0 1 1.0
17 17 Gordon, Julia 3 7 1 13 .462 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 1 0 0 0 7.0
4 4 Straub, Mehlayna 3 12 1 21 .524 0 0 0 2 0-2 1 2 0 0 0 0 14.0
1 1 Hickey, Reagan 3 0 0 1 .000 24 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 8 0 0 0.0
3 3 Nold, Makenna 3 13 9 33 .121 0 0 0 1 0-1 0 0 0 3 0 0 13.0
2 2 Waterman, Audrey 3 1 0 2 .500 22 0 0 0 0-0 0 2 0 3 0 0 2.0
9 9 Snoozy, Kaelyn 3 7 1 19 .316 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7.0
5 5 Tingelhoff, Josie 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1-1 0 0 0 6 0 0 1.0
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
Totals 56 15 126 .325 52 0 7 7 7-7 1 4 1 69 0 2 66
CSP - Individual
# Player SP Block Def Rec Pts
BS BA BE DIG BHE RE
12 12 Rolbiecki, Natalee 3 0 0 0 10 0 0 3.0
6 6 Sieling, Ellie 3 0 0 0 13 0 1 18.0
7 7 Sieling, Cassie 3 0 0 0 26 0 1 1.0
17 17 Gordon, Julia 3 0 0 1 0 0 0 7.0
4 4 Straub, Mehlayna 3 1 2 0 0 0 0 14.0
1 1 Hickey, Reagan 3 0 0 0 8 0 0 0.0
3 3 Nold, Makenna 3 0 0 0 3 0 0 13.0
2 2 Waterman, Audrey 3 0 2 0 3 0 0 2.0
9 9 Snoozy, Kaelyn 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 7.0
5 5 Tingelhoff, Josie 2 0 0 0 6 0 0 1.0
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
Totals 1 4 1 69 0 2 66

Play By Play

Set #1 Plays

Set #1 Plays
Serve Team UMC - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score CSP - Play Description
UMC 0 Concordia-St. Paul 1 [Muth, Carizma] Kill by Gordon, Julia (from Hickey, Reagan).
-- CSP subs: Rolbiecki, Natalee.
CSP [Rolbiecki, Natalee] Attack error by Nold, Makenna (from Sieling, Cassie). 1 Minn.-Crookston 1
UMC 1 Concordia-St. Paul 2 [Schnettler, Lauren] Kill by Nold, Makenna (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP 1 Concordia-St. Paul 3 [Sieling, Cassie] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP 1 Concordia-St. Paul 4 [Sieling, Cassie] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP 1 Concordia-St. Paul 5 [Sieling, Cassie] Service ace (Schnettler, Lauren).
CSP [Sieling, Cassie] Kill by Haag, Sophia (from Ehresmann, Ellery). 2 Minn.-Crookston 5
-- UMC subs: Melby, Dana; Schoenfelder, Megan.
UMC [Melby, Dana] Service ace (Sieling, Cassie). 3 Minn.-Crookston 5
UMC 3 Concordia-St. Paul 6 [Melby, Dana] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Hickey, Reagan).
-- CSP subs: Waterman, Audrey.
CSP [Nold, Makenna] Service error. 4 Minn.-Crookston 6
UMC 4 Concordia-St. Paul 7 [Carsten, Madison] Kill by Straub, Mehlayna (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP 4 Concordia-St. Paul 8 [Sieling, Ellie] Attack error by Muth, Carizma (block by Straub, Mehlayna; Waterman, Audrey).
CSP [Sieling, Ellie] Service error. 5 Minn.-Crookston 8
UMC 5 Concordia-St. Paul 9 [Malek, Emma] Service error.
CSP [Straub, Mehlayna] Service error. 6 Minn.-Crookston 9
UMC 6 Concordia-St. Paul 10 [Ehresmann, Ellery] Kill by Snoozy, Kaelyn (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP [Waterman, Audrey] Kill by Scharold, Lexi (from Ehresmann, Ellery). 7 Minn.-Crookston 10
UMC 7 Concordia-St. Paul 11 [Muth, Carizma] Kill by Nold, Makenna (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP 7 Concordia-St. Paul 12 [Rolbiecki, Natalee] Kill by Nold, Makenna (from Hickey, Reagan), block error by Carsten, Madison.
CSP 7 Concordia-St. Paul 13 [Rolbiecki, Natalee] Kill by Gordon, Julia (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP [Rolbiecki, Natalee] Kill by Carsten, Madison (from Ehresmann, Ellery), block error by Gordon, Julia. 8 Minn.-Crookston 13
UMC [Schnettler, Lauren] Kill by Carsten, Madison (from Ehresmann, Ellery). 9 Minn.-Crookston 13
UMC 9 Concordia-St. Paul 14 [Schnettler, Lauren] Service error.
CSP 9 Concordia-St. Paul 15 [Sieling, Cassie] Kill by Nold, Makenna (from Sieling, Cassie).
CSP 9 Concordia-St. Paul 16 [Sieling, Cassie] Bad set by Muth, Carizma.
CSP 9 Concordia-St. Paul 17 [Sieling, Cassie] Attack error by Malek, Emma (block by Straub, Mehlayna).
CSP [Sieling, Cassie] Kill by Carsten, Madison (from Muth, Carizma). 10 Minn.-Crookston 17
UMC 10 Concordia-St. Paul 18 [Melby, Dana] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Carsten, Madison).
CSP 10 Concordia-St. Paul 19 [Nold, Makenna] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Sieling, Cassie).
CSP [Nold, Makenna] Kill by Carsten, Madison (from Melby, Dana). 11 Minn.-Crookston 19
UMC 11 Concordia-St. Paul 20 [Carsten, Madison] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP 11 Concordia-St. Paul 21 [Sieling, Ellie] Service ace (Carsten, Madison).
CSP [Sieling, Ellie] Kill by Muth, Carizma (from Melby, Dana). 12 Minn.-Crookston 21
UMC [Malek, Emma] Kill by Schoenfelder, Megan (from Melby, Dana). 13 Minn.-Crookston 21
UMC 13 Concordia-St. Paul 22 [Malek, Emma] Kill by Straub, Mehlayna (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP [Straub, Mehlayna] Kill by Schoenfelder, Megan (from Melby, Dana). 14 Minn.-Crookston 22
UMC 14 Concordia-St. Paul 23 [Ehresmann, Ellery] Kill by Snoozy, Kaelyn (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP 14 Concordia-St. Paul 24 [Waterman, Audrey] Kill by Nold, Makenna (from Sieling, Cassie).
CSP 14 Concordia-St. Paul 25 [Waterman, Audrey] Kill by Gordon, Julia (from Haag, Sophia).

Set #2 Plays

Set #2 Plays
Serve Team UMC - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score CSP - Play Description
-- CSP subs: Hickey, Reagan; Rolbiecki, Natalee.
-- UMC subs: Schoenfelder, Megan; Melby, Dana.
CSP [Waterman, Audrey] Attack error by Nold, Makenna (from Waterman, Audrey). 1 Minn.-Crookston 0
-- CSP subs: Hickey, Reagan.
UMC 1 Concordia-St. Paul 1 [Schnettler, Lauren] Service error.
-- CSP subs: Rolbiecki, Natalee.
CSP 1 Concordia-St. Paul 2 [Rolbiecki, Natalee] Service ace (Schnettler, Lauren).
CSP 1 Concordia-St. Paul 3 [Rolbiecki, Natalee] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP [Rolbiecki, Natalee] Attack error by Nold, Makenna (from Hickey, Reagan). 2 Minn.-Crookston 3
-- UMC subs: Melby, Dana.
UMC [Melby, Dana] Attack error by Gordon, Julia (from Hickey, Reagan). 3 Minn.-Crookston 3
-- UMC subs: Schoenfelder, Megan.
UMC [Melby, Dana] Attack error by Nold, Makenna (block by Malek, Emma). 4 Minn.-Crookston 3
UMC 4 Concordia-St. Paul 4 [Melby, Dana] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP [Sieling, Cassie] Kill by Carsten, Madison (from Melby, Dana). 5 Minn.-Crookston 4
UMC 5 Concordia-St. Paul 5 [Carsten, Madison] Kill by Nold, Makenna (from Hickey, Reagan).
-- CSP subs: Tingelhoff, Josie.
CSP 5 Concordia-St. Paul 6 [Tingelhoff, Josie] Attack error by Carsten, Madison (from Melby, Dana).
CSP 5 Concordia-St. Paul 7 [Tingelhoff, Josie] Service ace (Team).
CSP [Tingelhoff, Josie] Kill by Muth, Carizma (from Melby, Dana). 6 Minn.-Crookston 7
UMC [Malek, Emma] Attack error by Sieling, Ellie (from Waterman, Audrey). 7 Minn.-Crookston 7
UMC 7 Concordia-St. Paul 8 [Malek, Emma] Kill by Waterman, Audrey (from Sieling, Cassie).
CSP 7 Concordia-St. Paul 9 [Sieling, Ellie] Kill by Straub, Mehlayna (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP [Sieling, Ellie] Kill by Scharold, Lexi (from Melby, Dana). 8 Minn.-Crookston 9
UMC 8 Concordia-St. Paul 10 [Ehresmann, Ellery] Kill by Straub, Mehlayna (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP [Straub, Mehlayna] Kill by Haag, Sophia (from Carsten, Madison). 9 Minn.-Crookston 10
UMC 9 Concordia-St. Paul 11 [Muth, Carizma] Kill by Gordon, Julia (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP 9 Concordia-St. Paul 12 [Waterman, Audrey] Kill by Nold, Makenna (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP 9 Concordia-St. Paul 13 [Waterman, Audrey] Kill by Gordon, Julia (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP [Waterman, Audrey] Kill by Scharold, Lexi (from Ehresmann, Ellery). 10 Minn.-Crookston 13
UMC 10 Concordia-St. Paul 14 [Schnettler, Lauren] Kill by Gordon, Julia (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP [Rolbiecki, Natalee] Attack error by Nold, Makenna (from Hickey, Reagan). 11 Minn.-Crookston 14
UMC [Melby, Dana] Attack error by Nold, Makenna (from Hickey, Reagan). 12 Minn.-Crookston 14
UMC 12 Concordia-St. Paul 15 [Melby, Dana] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP 12 Concordia-St. Paul 16 [Sieling, Cassie] Kill by Nold, Makenna (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP 12 Concordia-St. Paul 17 [Sieling, Cassie] Kill by Straub, Mehlayna (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP [Sieling, Cassie] Kill by Malek, Emma (from Melby, Dana). 13 Minn.-Crookston 17
UMC 13 Concordia-St. Paul 18 [Carsten, Madison] Kill by Nold, Makenna (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP [Tingelhoff, Josie] Attack error by Straub, Mehlayna (from Waterman, Audrey). 14 Minn.-Crookston 18
UMC [Malek, Emma] Kill by Scharold, Lexi (from Melby, Dana). 15 Minn.-Crookston 18
UMC 15 Concordia-St. Paul 19 [Malek, Emma] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP 15 Concordia-St. Paul 20 [Sieling, Ellie] Kill by Straub, Mehlayna (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP 15 Concordia-St. Paul 21 [Sieling, Ellie] Service ace (Schnettler, Lauren).
CSP [Sieling, Ellie] Kill by Schoenfelder, Megan (from Muth, Carizma). 16 Minn.-Crookston 21
UMC 16 Concordia-St. Paul 22 [Ehresmann, Ellery] Kill by Straub, Mehlayna (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP 16 Concordia-St. Paul 23 [Straub, Mehlayna] Attack error by Muth, Carizma (from Ehresmann, Ellery).
CSP [Straub, Mehlayna] Kill by Muth, Carizma (from Ehresmann, Ellery). 17 Minn.-Crookston 23
UMC [Muth, Carizma] Service ace (Sieling, Ellie). 18 Minn.-Crookston 23
UMC 18 Concordia-St. Paul 24 [Muth, Carizma] Kill by Snoozy, Kaelyn (from Sieling, Ellie).
CSP [Waterman, Audrey] Attack error by Snoozy, Kaelyn (from Waterman, Audrey). 19 Minn.-Crookston 24
UMC [Schnettler, Lauren] Attack error by Nold, Makenna (from Hickey, Reagan). 20 Minn.-Crookston 24
UMC 20 Concordia-St. Paul 25 [Schnettler, Lauren] Attack error by Muth, Carizma (from Carsten, Madison).

Set #3 Plays

Set #3 Plays
Serve Team UMC - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score CSP - Play Description
-- CSP subs: Waterman, Audrey; Tingelhoff, Josie; Rolbiecki, Natalee.
-- UMC subs: Schoenfelder, Megan; Melby, Dana.
UMC 0 Concordia-St. Paul 1 [Muth, Carizma] Kill by Snoozy, Kaelyn (from Hickey, Reagan).
-- CSP subs: Rolbiecki, Natalee.
CSP 0 Concordia-St. Paul 2 [Rolbiecki, Natalee] Service ace (Team).
CSP 0 Concordia-St. Paul 3 [Rolbiecki, Natalee] Attack error by Carsten, Madison (from Ehresmann, Ellery).
CSP [Rolbiecki, Natalee] Service error. 1 Minn.-Crookston 3
UMC 1 Concordia-St. Paul 4 [Schnettler, Lauren] Kill by Gordon, Julia (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP 1 Concordia-St. Paul 5 [Sieling, Cassie] Kill by Straub, Mehlayna (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP 1 Concordia-St. Paul 6 [Sieling, Cassie] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP [Sieling, Cassie] Service error. 2 Minn.-Crookston 6
-- UMC subs: Melby, Dana; Schoenfelder, Megan.
UMC 2 Concordia-St. Paul 7 [Melby, Dana] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Sieling, Cassie).
-- CSP subs: Waterman, Audrey.
CSP 2 Concordia-St. Paul 8 [Nold, Makenna] Attack error by Carsten, Madison (block by Straub, Mehlayna; Waterman, Audrey).
CSP 2 Concordia-St. Paul 9 [Nold, Makenna] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP 2 Concordia-St. Paul 10 [Nold, Makenna] Kill by Straub, Mehlayna (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP [Nold, Makenna] Attack error by Nold, Makenna (from Waterman, Audrey). 3 Minn.-Crookston 10
UMC 3 Concordia-St. Paul 11 [Carsten, Madison] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP [Sieling, Ellie] Kill by Malek, Emma (from Melby, Dana). 4 Minn.-Crookston 11
UMC 4 Concordia-St. Paul 12 [Malek, Emma] Kill by Nold, Makenna.
CSP [Straub, Mehlayna] Kill by Scharold, Lexi (from Melby, Dana). 5 Minn.-Crookston 12
UMC 5 Concordia-St. Paul 13 [Ehresmann, Ellery] Kill by Snoozy, Kaelyn (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP [Waterman, Audrey] Kill by Scharold, Lexi (from Ehresmann, Ellery). 6 Minn.-Crookston 13
UMC 6 Concordia-St. Paul 14 [Muth, Carizma] Kill by Nold, Makenna (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP 6 Concordia-St. Paul 15 [Rolbiecki, Natalee] Kill by Nold, Makenna (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP 6 Concordia-St. Paul 16 [Rolbiecki, Natalee] Service ace (Schnettler, Lauren).
CSP [Rolbiecki, Natalee] Attack error by Sieling, Ellie (from Hickey, Reagan). 7 Minn.-Crookston 16
UMC [Schnettler, Lauren] Attack error by Nold, Makenna (from Hickey, Reagan). 8 Minn.-Crookston 16
UMC 8 Concordia-St. Paul 17 [Schnettler, Lauren] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Hickey, Reagan).
CSP [Sieling, Cassie] Attack error by Sieling, Ellie (block by Haag, Sophia; Malek, Emma). 9 Minn.-Crookston 17
UMC [Melby, Dana] Kill by Carsten, Madison (from Schnettler, Lauren). 10 Minn.-Crookston 17
UMC 10 Concordia-St. Paul 18 [Melby, Dana] Kill by Nold, Makenna (from Hickey, Reagan).
-- CSP subs: Tingelhoff, Josie.
CSP 10 Concordia-St. Paul 19 [Tingelhoff, Josie] Kill by Straub, Mehlayna (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP 10 Concordia-St. Paul 20 [Tingelhoff, Josie] Kill by Straub, Mehlayna (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP [Tingelhoff, Josie] Service error. 11 Minn.-Crookston 20
UMC 11 Concordia-St. Paul 21 [Carsten, Madison] Kill by Sieling, Ellie (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP 11 Concordia-St. Paul 22 [Sieling, Ellie] Kill by Straub, Mehlayna.
CSP [Sieling, Ellie] Kill by Schoenfelder, Megan (from Melby, Dana). 12 Minn.-Crookston 22
UMC 12 Concordia-St. Paul 23 [Malek, Emma] Kill by Snoozy, Kaelyn (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP [Straub, Mehlayna] Service error. 13 Minn.-Crookston 23
UMC [Ehresmann, Ellery] Kill by Muth, Carizma (from Ehresmann, Ellery). 14 Minn.-Crookston 23
UMC 14 Concordia-St. Paul 24 [Ehresmann, Ellery] Kill by Snoozy, Kaelyn (from Waterman, Audrey).
CSP 14 Concordia-St. Paul 25 [Waterman, Audrey] Attack error by Muth, Carizma (from Ehresmann, Ellery).