| NSIC Player of the Year |
| 2012 |
Bryan Lippincott |
|
|
| NSIC Pitcher of the Year |
| 2018 |
Gus Varland |
| 2009 |
Jake Schmidt |
| 2007 |
Matt Borman |
|
|
| NSIC Newcomer of the Year |
| 2024 |
Bennett McCollow |
|
| 2008 |
Joe Abellera |
| 2004 |
Jon Schemmel |
| 2003 |
Matt Borman |
| 2000 |
Travis Anderson |
|
|
| NSIC Freshman of the Year |
| 2006 |
Alex Kubal |
|
|
| NSIC Coach of the Year |
| 2005 |
Mark McKenzie |
|
|
| All-NSIC First Team |
| 2024 |
Bennett McCollow, Nick Thimsen |
| 2018 |
Gus Varland |
| 2017 |
Isaac Hormann |
| 2016 |
Connor Olson |
| 2014 |
Kyle Dalton |
| 2012 |
Bryan Lippincott |
| 2010 |
Brenden Furrow |
| 2009 |
Jake Schmidt, Chris Herbert |
| 2008 |
Jake Schmidt, Chris Herbert, Jake Waldman, Brenden?Furrow, Joe Abellera |
| 2007 |
Matt Borman (2x: P & OF), Jake Waldman, Andy Judkins |
| 2006 |
Erik Quarberg, Geoff Bray, Galen Wetzell, Bobby Meier, Chris Duda, Alex Kubal, Tony Boxwell |
| 2005 |
Geoff Bray, Jon Schemmel, Chris Duda, Galen Wetzell, Erik Quarberg |
| 2004 |
Jon Schemmel, Galen Wetzell, Matt Borman, Erik Quarberg |
| 2003 |
Matt Borman, Bill Mauer |
| 2002 |
Joe Shallenberger, Lee Brandel, Adam Sobiech |
| 2001 |
Joe Shallenberger |
| 2000 |
Travis Anderson |
|
|
| All-NSIC Second Team |
| 2022 |
Kal Brohmer |
| 2021 |
Nick Thimsen, Jarod Wandersee |
| 2018 |
Louie Varland, Drew Sannes |
| 2017 |
Carter Schmidt |
| 2015 |
Eric Fasnacht |
| 2013 |
Adam Kramer, Greg Larpenter |
| 2011 |
Bryan Lippincott, Jon Stockton |
| 2010 |
Bryan Lippincott, Blake DeVries |
| 2009 |
Brenden Furrow |
| 2008 |
Zane Froehlich |
| 2007 |
Greg Winegarden |
|
|
| All-NSIC Honorable Mention |
| 2006 |
Kirk Ingram, Mason Reinhart |
| 2005 |
Jacob Campion, Bobby Meier |
| 2004 |
Jacob Campion, Adam Flaherty |
| 2003 |
Andrew Wehr, Travis Anderson |
| 2002 |
David Schlundt, Bobby Dennis |
| 2001 |
Lee Brandel, Rob Higgins |
| 2000 |
Dustin Campbell, Anthony Zecco |
|
|
| All-NSIC Gold Glove Team |
| 2023 |
Mason Wolf (OF) |
| 2018 |
Connor Olson (C) |
| 2017 |
Isaac Hormann (2B) |
| 2012 |
Greg Larpenter (OF) |
| 2011 |
Sam Fagely (OF) |
|
|
| NSIC Tournament MVP |
| 2008 |
Jake Schmidt (Pitcher), Brenden?Furrow (Player) |
| 2003 |
Matt Borman (Pitcher) |
|
|
| NSIC All-Tournament Team |
| 2024 |
Bennett McCollow |
| 2018 |
Patrick Bordewick, Carter Schmidt, Gus Varland |
| 2016 |
Connor Olson, Eric Fasnacht, Gus Varland |
| 2015 |
Eric Fasnacht |
| 2013 |
Ryan Poppitz |
| 2008 |
Jake Schmidt, Brenden Furrow, Chris Herbert, Ted Farni, Blake DeVries |
| 2007 |
Matt Borman, Jake Schmidt |
| 2006 |
Geoff Bray, Bobby Meier, Chris Duda, Erik Quarberg |
| 2003 |
Matt Borman, Bill Mauer, Bobby Dennis, Galen Wetzell, Andy Hanson, Travis Anderson |
