Concordia-St. Paul athletics joined the Northern Sun and NCAA Division II ranks for the 1999-2000 basketball season. The following players have earned All-Northern Sun Conference honors and NSIC Player of the Week accolades:
NSICÂ PLAYER OF THE YEAR AWARD
Antwan Kimmons, 2024-25
NSIC NEWCOMER OF THE YEAR AWARD
Peter Olafeso, 2010-11
Isaiah McKay, 2018-19
Antwan Kimmons, 2022-23
ALL-NSIC FIRST TEAM SELECTIONS
Brian Jamros, 2003-04
Brian Jamros, 2004-05
Kyle Marxhausen, 2006-07
Craig Heiman, 2007-08
Craig Heiman, 2008-09
Craig Heiman, 2009-10
Peter Olafeso, 2010-11 - Newcomer of the Year
Antwan Kimmons, 2022-23
Antwan Kimmons, 2024-25
Marcus Skeete, 2024-25
ALL-NSIC SECOND TEAM SELECTIONS
Justin Vandenberg, 2004-05
Ty Thomas, 2005-06
Mike Cunningham, 2008-09
Brent Barz, 2009-10
Brent Barz, 2010-11
Peter Olafeso, 2011-12
Terez VanPelt, 2012-13
Terez VanPelt, 2013-14
Terez VanPelt, 2014-15
Cole Olstad, 2014-15
Cole Olstad, 2015-16
Bryndan Matthews, 2018-19
Cade Meyer, 2024-25
ALL-NSIC THIRD TEAM SELECTIONS
Joey Peel, 2006-07
James Metcalf, 2007-08
ALL-NSIC HONORABLE MENTION
Josh Delich, 1999-00
Josh Delich, 2000-01
Josh Delich, 2001-02
AWARDS PRE-DIVISION II ERA
All-UPPER MIDWEST CONFERENCE
Paul Clausen, 1984-85
Curt Kietzer, 1984-85 (honorable mention)
Kevin Pattain, 1984-85 (honorable mention)
Paul Hagen, 1985-86 (honorable mention)
Paul Hagen, 1986-87
Kreigh Dobbins, 1986-87 (honorable mention)
Curt Frieman, 1986-87 (honorable mention)
ALL-CONCORDIA INVITATIONAL TOURNAMENT (CIT) TEAM
Kevin Pattain, 1984-85
Paul Hagen, 1986-87
Dan Wolff, 1988-89
